A great deal of fantasy literature these days is what I would call medieval-themed. That is, the story is set in a society that bears many resemblances to that of the Middle Ages. For this, JRR Tolkien is largely responsible—he studied real medieval literature (primarily Nordic and Anglo-Saxon) and set his own stories in a milieu that bore a resemblance to that found in the literature he studied. Fantasy as a modern genre begins with him.
(Of course not all modern fantasy is medieval-themed. As I have discussed earlier, one can write perfectly good fantasy set in something that reminds one of the twentieth or twenty-first century. But the predominant form of fantasy remains medieval adjacent, at least.)
This brings us to the people who invented the genre of fantasy, authors living in the Middle Ages. The genre really started in the eleventh and twelfth centuries, with epics like The Song of Roland and romances like Tristan and Isolde. (The distinction between epic and romance isn't worth worrying about. Modern literary scholars make much of the distinction, but I doubt medieval authors did.)
(Shameless plug: Here's my own retelling of Tristan and Isolde.)
Medieval authors set their fantastic stories in something close to their own world, but with the addition of magic, or at least marvelous people and things, with characters larger than life. (Or, as in the case of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, huge green headless knights.) Topics like latrines or dirty socks did not come up (although latrines featured largely in stories about demons, who tended to hang out in such smelly places, or attack evil doers while they were sitting there). (One might consider stories of saints and demons another version of medieval fantasy, except that their authors considered those real, unlike the fictional epics and romances.)
These stories were often set in an imagined past, when men were men and women were women (and as Garrison Keillor would add, little fuzzy animals were little fuzzy animals). There was an artificial nostalgia in these stories for some long ago time when heroes were truly heroic, and honor and love received their due. King Arthur stories, both the English and the French versions, were often explicitly set in the late Roman Empire, even though the late Empire had nothing like the knights and castles of which the stories were full, elements from the authors' own tmes. Stories of Charlemagne written in the eleventh-thirteenth centuries similarly gave the emperor knights and castles of the eleventh-thirteenth century variety.
Stories about characters larger than life, and with such wondrous possessions as a sword that would not break, or a green samite comforter stuffed with eiderdown, or mountains of fresh, delicious fruit were intended to do more than entertain. They made comments about their contemporary society. By setting their stories in an imaginary past, authors were able to avoid the criticism that they were being openly political, but few would have missed the point.
For example, tales of William of Orange, supposedly set in the time of Charlemagne, mocked the great, chivalric hero at the same time as they made him the central character, indicating that being big and bold and a wonderful fighter could too easily become ridiculous. Similarly, stories of Lancelot, which quickly became a central aspect of the older King Arthur stories, were stories of the world's greatest knight, who commits gross adultery and eventually brings down the whole kingdom.
Interestingly, the world in which medieval authors set their stories tended to become frozen around the thirteenth century. The King Arthur stories, in the version in which they are best known today, were heavily shaped by Mallory, who brought them all together in the fifteenth century. And yet Mallory's knights of the Round Table fight with sword and lance. No sign of the guns and cannons that had become a central aspect of warfare in his time. Hey, these stories are set in the past!
Modern fantasy writers follow suit. They rarely include anything to do with gunpowder. Even George RR Martin, whose grim tales of alliance and treachery are set in something like the War of the Roses, keeps his (fairly realistic, other than dragons) medieval setting firmly comparable to Europe two centuries before the War of the Roses.
Other fantasy authors (including me!) may (at least sometimes) create a fantasy world that has much of the social structures of Jane Austen's time (early nineteenth century) combined with the weapons and transportation of the twelfth century. One may have towns, lawyers, farmers who are not serfs, a postal system, nice cloth in the stores, even (sometimes) stage coaches, but swords for weapons and horses to get you anywhere.
© C. Dale Brittain 2026

No comments:
Post a Comment